MIDI troubleshooting guide

Do drums make MIDI conversion worse?

Not before chords do in this controlled source check. The melody-only fixture retained 7 of 8 notes; adding chord triads reduced retention to zero, and adding drums afterward did not change the median.

Melody only retains seven of eight notes; adding chords then chords plus drums retains zero of eight notes in both cases.
The harmonic layer set the tested boundary before percussion was added.
Short answer: if chords and melody arrive together, isolate the melody first. Do not assume removing drums alone will recover it. Best with one exposed melody, not chords or a full mix.

Try one exposed melody

Controlled mixture check

8-note target sourceMedian across 10 fixturesWhat changed
Melody only7 retained; 1 missed; 0 extraBaseline single-line result
Melody + chord triads0 retained; 8 missed; 3 extraChord competition entered
Melody + chord triads + kick and high percussion0 retained; 8 missed; 3 extraNo further median change

What to change in the source

This does not say drums never matter. It says they were not the variable that changed this fixture after chords were already present. Choose an exposed vocal, solo, or single-note phrase, or isolate the target line before conversion.

Fixture conditions and limits

Each level used 10 generated mono 44.1 kHz 16-bit PCM WAV fixtures. The target was an eight-note melody; chord levels added three simultaneous tones per target note; the third level added a 90 Hz kick and high-percussion pulse. Balanced Melody / solo instrument mode used a 2048-sample analysis window and a 1024-sample hop. A retained note needed one output within 50 cents and at least 50% overlap. Detector SHA-256: DDA185AC8FB6A179A4FCFA73FD4197ACC95B8B6F59B233F5D3E330F596309F9F.

These are controlled source checks, not a complete-song, stem-separation, chord-transcription, drum-transcription, or universal accuracy promise.

Related: song-to-MIDI source boundary · audio-to-MIDI source checks · no stable pitch