MP3 to MIDI source check

Does MP3 compression hurt MIDI conversion?

Not in this clean, single-melody fixture: MP3 at 128, 192, and 320 kbps, AAC at 128 kbps, and Opus at 128 kbps each retained all 8 notes. That result applies to this source, not every compressed song.

Five codec test cards show eight of eight notes retained.
Five encodes of the same 8-note source; every point retained 8 of 8 notes.
Short answer: for one exposed, clean melody, encoding was not the variable in this check. Try the file you have, then inspect its note line. Best with one exposed melody, not chords or a full mix.

Upload an audio file

Controlled codec check

Encoded source Median across 10 fixtures Result
MP3 128 kbps 8 retained; 0 missed; 0 extra 8 / 8 notes retained
MP3 192 kbps 8 retained; 0 missed; 0 extra 8 / 8 notes retained
MP3 320 kbps 8 retained; 0 missed; 0 extra 8 / 8 notes retained
AAC 128 kbps 8 retained; 0 missed; 0 extra 8 / 8 notes retained
Opus 128 kbps 8 retained; 0 missed; 0 extra 8 / 8 notes retained

What this result does and does not say

The fixture was an alternating C4/E4 melody: 8 no-gap notes, 80 ms per note, rendered first as mono 44.1 kHz 16-bit PCM WAV. It does not establish that platform compression is harmless for a full song, a chordal mix, or another source. It shows only that the tested encodes did not change retained, missed, or extra-event medians in this fixture.

Fixture conditions and limits

Each encoded source had 10 repetitions. The detector used Balanced Melody / solo instrument mode, a 2048-sample analysis window, and a 1024-sample hop. A declared input note was valid at 50 ms or longer; retained meant exactly one output overlapping at least 50% and within 50 cents; extra meant an unmatched output or second output for one input. Detector SHA-256: DDA185AC8FB6A179A4FCFA73FD4197ACC95B8B6F59B233F5D3E330F596309F9F.

These are controlled source checks, not a universal audio-compression or accuracy promise.

Related: audio-to-MIDI source checks · export audio from a YouTube video first · short notes and event timing